ever_neutral: (hp ~ whomp)
[personal profile] ever_neutral
They Don’t Write Songs About The Ones That Don’t Break Your Rules (Or 13 Times Hermione Granger Doesn’t Necessarily Succeed At Following Her Own, And One Time She Metaphorically Throws Them Off The Astronomy Tower)
Harry Potter, Hermione Granger, Ron/Hermione
PS-DH, 2,179 words
A/N: MY IDEA OF A BIRTHDAY PRESENT TO LAUREN. I should also warn that the following is unbeta-ed, and written in approximately two hours, and also my first time with these kids, so POSSIBLY TERRIBLE.
There has never been much elegance in their dance, because she is who she is, and they are who they are, and they don’t write love stories about the ones that never get it right.

01.

He makes her cry within the first two months of school. And it’s awful, because she shouldn’t care, and she doesn’t care, she doesn’t care about his words, because they don’t mean anything - even as they cut right to the bone, and she’s reminded of how pathetically breakable she is.

She cannot forgive him for this. She promises she never will.



02.

She leaves that bathroom stall, slowly, because it still hurts, and the proof is there in the redness of her eyes and the tear tracks on her cheeks. And the monster greets her, the first she’s really encountered, and she realises that she might die here, in this cold empty bathroom, alone. It’s the sort of ending that would come as a shock, but an expected one.

What really truly does shock, is the sight of him stumbling through the door, wand nervously raised, just a step behind his famously more heroic friend (whom she might have expected).

But this is a twist. This is not the role she’s assigned to him, these are the not the lines she’s learnt off by heart. He’s taking her words, the ones she made sure to pronounce just right – and he’s delivering them better than she could have written them.

For the first time in her life, she is unsure how this will end.


--


03.

They’ve been friends for a long enough time for it to hurt just that much when a silly squabble over pets, of all things, leads to him not talking to her for weeks.

She considers apologising - don’t misunderstand, she considers doing so many times, if only because it might restore things, and anything would be preferable to this stony silence, and you know things are really wrong when the two of them have nothing to say to one another.

But then she remembers that there is nothing to apologise for, there simply isn’t any proof, it just wouldn’t be logical, and rationality in these matters (of love, friendship and bravery) is what’s really necessary to hold on to.

Particularly when his argument boils down to the idea that she’s a heartless vicious monster who thinks nothing of tearing other living things apart. It’s an utterly nonsensical proposition, a disappointing play coming from him of all people, and yet one that manages to defeat her entirely.

(Part of her wants to laugh at the idea that she’d be the one responsible for ripping the other apart.)



04.

It’s only after it’s over -- the stand-off, this stalemate, this lull waiting for one of them to break (and she does, and it’s sort of embarrassing to throw her arms around him so tearfully, but there was never much dignity in love anyway, though she doesn’t dwell on that) – does she realise she’s been holding her breath, and at his bracing words (”You won’t have to do all the work alone this time, Hermione. I’ll help”), she exhales.

And it dawns on her that this is not just a game anymore.


--


05.

She’d thought that there could be nothing worse than that first incident, his verbal reminder of her perpetual loneliness, but this – this pathetic excuse for a romantic invitation is like a slap in the face. Oh, he has outdone himself.

And it’s for this reason that she decides to blame him instead of herself for her next slip: “Just because it's taken you three years to notice, Ron, doesn't mean no one else has spotted I'm a girl!” Thankfully, he doesn’t seem to notice her mistake, which she guesses is a blessing of sorts (though with him it’s difficult to tell, and the outcome of that first incident back in their first year has taught her that).

So she has the time to draw up a list for herself, and by the time she’s finished making it, she is certain that even if his proposition hadn’t been so utterly weak, and even if someone else hadn’t spotted first, the answer would always be no, and the solution to the problem would never be him.

(Especially when he’s the cause of it. But she doesn’t dwell on that.)

The idea of them actually dancing together is preposterous, anyway. They’d fit all wrong, their timing would be completely off, and he would doubtless step on her toes a dozen times because this is who they are, after all.

And should they ever be in the position of being face-to-face, actually touching and connecting, her eyes would (misguidedly) find his, only for him to look away.

Or the other way around. They have always taken turns to make the wrong move.



06.

The next time she slips, it’s a far more grievous mistake, one that even Harry is privy to, and she doesn’t know how she will ever get over this failure. She’d nearly succeeded too, but just like that, her adamant plans - to surprise everybody, to enjoy this night - are in ruins, and just a few cutting words were enough to undo them. The damage is done, the holes in her armour are plain for all to see, and she has no choice but to retreat with the last scraps of her dignity.

“Well – that just proves – completely missed the point –“ She hears him sputter behind her, but she doesn’t care, the damage is done, she doesn’t care.

Her only remote comfort is that he is just as undone as she is.

It’s no victory.


--


07.

“Gee, Harry’s been gone a long time, hey.”

She feels herself blushing. “Well, it looked like he was going to talk with Cho for a bit.”

She feels his gaze on her. “Right. Well.” He coughs nervously for a bit, and then there’s silence.

They stay like that for a while, until finally he breaks the ice again. “Be weird if they start, you know…” He trails off, and she guesses it’s up to her to fill in the blanks. What are the missing pieces, Ron? What are you not telling me?

“Yes, I suppose,” she replies.

“I mean… D’you think he’ll start not caring about us so much?” He speaks carefully, and there’s something beneath his words that she senses is begging to come out.

She feels a flash of annoyance, because it’s not her role to dig his meaning out for him, and it’s so unfair that he expects her to do that, and make your own meaning, for goodness’ sake.

Then she remembers that yes, in fact, yes, this is her part. And it’s the one he trusts her to do, it’s the space he doesn’t trust anyone else to fill.

“That will never happen,” she answers him.


--


08.

She sees him wrapped around Lavender Brown, and she doesn’t know how to battle the fury in her veins, and worse yet, the coiling despair in her gut. The simultaneous reactions leave her at a loss, and to add insult to injury, she has lost him to a girl she wasn’t even aware she was competing against.

(She recognises she has only been made aware that she is competing at all, yes, but it doesn’t matter, because she should have known earlier, she should have known. She has never been so slow on the uptake.)

She has never felt more disappointed in herself.



09.

“I’m really not playing as well as I should be,” Harry declares, morosely, over his Astronomy notes. “I don’t know what’s wrong with me.”

“Yes, well, we don’t always live up to our own standards, Harry,” she says, and her voice is clipped.

He is probably taken aback at the level of unconcealed bitterness in her voice, but she doesn’t have the will to reassure him it will fade. She doesn’t have it in her to play the role she’s supposed to.

(She simply can’t do anything right anymore.)

Ron Weasley approaches the table with Seamus Finnigan, trading some stupid joke or other. She is too furious to see if it’s even funny. She grabs her books, none too gently, and marches swiftly away in the other direction. She is careful to take her dignity with her.

“What the hell is her problem,” she hears him say in an irritated manner, faintly, somewhere behind her.

She thinks she might like to wait and hear if he figures it out, but the door is just ahead of her, and so she does the only thing she can do, and she leaves through it.



10.

He’s come to join them this time, to spend time with his old friends for once, instead of with her, and well done Ron Weasley, a hundred points, for knowing what really matters after all, even if you’re not remotely close to figuring it out.

She feels simultaneously gleeful and disgusted, and it doesn’t make sense at all, that she should be compelled to sway towards him and recoil at the same time, and frankly, she is sick of the contradiction.

(She’d rather have the disgust.)

He’s moaning about Quidditch again, which is thoroughly predictable of course. And he’s fretting about all the pressure on him, and how he doesn’t think he’ll be able to do it, and he’s looking for some sort of answer, but she knows that any attempt at showing him she cares will either be ignored or spat on, because that’s the easy way out in these matters, and she’s beginning to see the appeal.

So she laughs, short and cruel, murmurs a thoroughly insincere “good luck”, and both boys look at her in utter amazement, because neither of them knew she had this in her, you see. She allows herself to feel smug about this card she has been hiding, that she has totally defeated him with.

“You know what, Hermione?” he says, and she waits for what he’ll do next.

(Because what’s a couple more seconds on top of the years she’s been waiting, and it’s impossible, unbearable, that she has been waiting for what he’ll do next, all the time she has known him.)

“I hate you,” comes the second part of his response. It’s a thoroughly underwhelming shot, disappointing really, but she can’t help hitting back, because she is who she is, and they are who they are.

“I hate you right back,” she shoots back, and she is proud of the conviction in her voice, and the sharp snap with which she closes her book and slams it down. She is proud of the steel in her limbs as she walks away, and she is proud of herself for not looking back.



11.

It’s true, she has always had her pride, and she’s held tight to it in the knowledge that it is the one thing that will never leave her. And she has never realised what a sin that pride is until she’s staring at his unconscious body in the bleakness of the hospital wing.



12.

To be quite honest, she’s not even sure if she’s completely forgiven him, except that there’s been enough pain and separation the last few months, and he at least owes her an apology for that.

Then he mutters her name in his sleep, barely decipherable.

It’s no apology, and this is no perfect reunion, with their surroundings of hospital beds and the various bystanders witnessing their dysfunction.

But (she is surprised to realise) she has long stopped defining perfection the way she used to.


--


13.

She curls herself up in her sheets as the wind howls around them, just mere inches away - and really, Harry might be grateful for her foresight and thorough packing, but the walls of this tent (this makeshift fortress she has built) are far too thin to protect them much. This is the story of her life.

And she is ready to accept it now, here in the near-dark, with the tinny radio crackling in the corner, with one of her best friends gone, and her other best friend not looking at her, and the wind screaming like a banshee mourning their lost love: She is not, never has been, and never will be the maiden in the ivory tower, and her walls crumbled long ago.



14.

And then he comes back, and he’s full of maddening apologies and preposterous stories and unbearably sincere remorse. And he talks about her voice leading him back, just like something out of a magic fable. And it’s preposterous, because they might live in a world of magic, but there has never been much elegance in their dance, because she is who she is, and they are who they are, and they don’t write love stories about the ones that never get it right.

“And what exactly did I say?” she asks.

And she waits, for the answer that will come but will inevitably fail to answer anything, because there has never been an answer, and if she hasn’t been able to figure it out, then no one will. She looks at him, and she waits.

And he replies, “My name.”

And she thinks, Oh.

So that was it.



*

Date: 2011-01-06 05:09 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] angearia.livejournal.com
Oh wow. This is beautiful. I think this might be the first HP fic I've ever read and I'm sure you've thoroughly spoiled me.

This is so Hermione. I could hear her all the way through. Your language even managed to capture the cadence of a British accent which made it all the more convincing. And what beautiful language it was.

And I was already enjoying it, already finding a great appreciation for Hermione and Ron, and then I got to the end and it was so perfect.

I loved it. ♥

Date: 2011-01-07 03:21 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
OMG I AM HONOURED TO BE YOUR (possible) FIRST. And I am so, so pleased it worked for you! And made you appreciate my kids!!!

Thanks so much, bb. ♥

Date: 2011-01-06 05:50 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] pocochina.livejournal.com
YOU HAVE AN UNUSUAL DEFINITION OF TERRIBLE, MY DEAR. This is fantastic.

Then she remembers that yes, in fact, yes, this is her part. And it’s the one he trusts her to do, it’s the space he doesn’t trust anyone else to fill.

yes.

the walls of this tent (this makeshift fortress she has built) are far too thin to protect them much. This is the story of her life.

oh.

Date: 2011-01-07 03:26 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
Thank you!! ♥

Date: 2011-01-06 06:07 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] blackfrancine.livejournal.com
and they don’t write love stories about the ones that never get it right.

Oh my god. I'm pretty sure you just ripped out my heart.

And he replies, “My name.”

And she thinks, Oh.

So that was it.


And then put it back in.

Like Emmie, I've never read HPfic before--and this was amazing.

Date: 2011-01-07 03:32 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
AAAAA Y'ALL ARE TOO KIND. ♥

Congrats on losing your HP fic virginity, dude - and thanks for the lovely feedback!

Date: 2011-01-06 11:41 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] penny-lane-42.livejournal.com
OMG I CAN'T WAIT TO READ THIS AS SOON AS I GET HOME FROM THE SYMPHONY OMG I AM SO EXCIIIIIITED!

Date: 2011-01-07 03:13 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
OMG YOU ARE AT A SYMPHONY ADL;FJAD;KLF

Date: 2011-01-07 04:05 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] penny-lane-42.livejournal.com
Hahaha! Yes, I was at the symphony, but now I am back and in awe of your giiiiift.

The idea of them actually dancing together is preposterous, anyway. They’d fit all wrong, their timing would be completely off, and he would doubtless step on her toes a dozen times because this is who they are, after all.

And should they ever be in the position of being face-to-face, actually touching and connecting, her eyes would (misguidedly) find his, only for him to look away.

Or the other way around. They have always taken turns to make the wrong move.


*FLAILS AND FLAILS AND FLAILS FOREVER* I CANNOT TELL YOU HOW PERFECTLY THEM THIS IS.


“I mean… D’you think he’ll start not caring about us so much?” He speaks carefully, and there’s something beneath his words that she senses is begging to come out.

She feels a flash of annoyance, because it’s not her role to dig his meaning out for him, and it’s so unfair that he expects her to do that, and make your own meaning, for goodness’ sake.

Then she remembers that yes, in fact, yes, this is her part. And it’s the one he trusts her to do, it’s the space he doesn’t trust anyone else to fill.

“That will never happen,” she answers him.


OMG LAYERED CONVERSATION ON MULTIPLE LEVELS AND THE ROLES THEY'VE MADE FOR EACH OTHER!

she has lost him to a girl she wasn’t even aware she was competing against.

This line hit me in the gut.


(Because what’s a couple more seconds on top of the years she’s been waiting, and it’s impossible, unbearable, that she has been waiting for what he’ll do next, all the time she has known him.)


OH MY KIIIIIIIDS.


But (she is surprised to realise) she has long stopped defining perfection the way she used to.

EXACTLY, GIRL. BECAUSE RON WEASLEY IS THE NEW DEFINITION OF PERFECTION.

And it’s preposterous, because they might live in a world of magic, but there has never been much elegance in their dance, because she is who she is, and they are who they are, and they don’t write love stories about the ones that never get it right.

THIS IS THEM IN A NUTSHELL, ISN'T IT?

And he replies, “My name.”

And she thinks, Oh.

So that was it.


I THINK YOU MIGHT HAVE KILLED ME WITH PERFECTION.

But seriously, this is perfect and so very them, and it makes me ache in all the right ways, and I love you so much for writing them and did I mention that this is perfect? ♥

Date: 2011-01-07 06:42 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
AAAAAAAA I AM SO ECSTATIC YOU LIIIIIKE. ♥

These kids, man. I tell you, this thing pretty much wrote itself, because they are the perfect ~them~ already in canon, and it was just a matter of digging into that imperfect perfection.

BECAUSE RON WEASLEY IS THE NEW DEFINITION OF PERFECTION.

PREACH, WOMAN.

Oh, Lauren, your flail is infectious. I LOVE IT AND I LOVE YOU AND I LOVE OUR KIIIIDS. SO MUCH LOVE. ♥ ♥ ♥

P.S. Hope the symphony was wicked awesome.
From: [identity profile] aerintine.livejournal.com
I... don't have the words for how much I love this. My heart, lady. You just squeezed it til it burst.

PERFECTION.

I seriously can't type properly. I am agog. I can't believe that you (a) wrote this in 2 hours and (b) do not see that it is the most perfect thing there ever was ever.

Oh, my kids. My heart is so full of them all the time these days and they just keep coming and won't let anyone else in because they are guarding the door and I cannot love them enough. And then you write this and, impossibly, I love them more.

Then she remembers that yes, in fact, yes, this is her part. And it’s the one he trusts her to do, it’s the space he doesn’t trust anyone else to fill.

*dies of happiness*

He’s taking her words, the ones she made sure to pronounce just right – and he’s delivering them better than she could have written them.

Only because he learned them from her. Because he learned everything from her. Gorgeous, gorgeous.

and it’s impossible, unbearable, that she has been waiting for what he’ll do next, all the time she has known him

Oh, I can feel the furious clenching of her heart and fists -what this realization means - of how he is her center, which means she will be forever spinning. Oh, Hermione! Oh, my heart.


She looks at him, and she waits.

And he replies, “My name.”

And she thinks, Oh.

So that was it.


And that's when my heart burst open. Hermione and Ron perfection love forever and ever amen.

I love you for writing our kids with such beauty. Thank you. Thank you thank you.
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
AL;FAKJDFD;A

I DO NOT KNOW WHAT TO SAY TO ALL THAT??? Except that I am so happy this speaks to you because I know how much these kids mean to you, and the way we see them means WE ARE ONE.

My heart is so full of them all the time these days and they just keep coming and won't let anyone else in because they are guarding the door and I cannot love them enough.

I know what you mean. I think there's sort of an assumption that R/Hr are so popular because of nostalgia and emotional immaturity or something but... nah. A decade on, they still sock me in the gut. IT WAS REAL, YO.

Oh, I can feel the furious clenching of her heart and fists -what this realization means - of how he is her center, which means she will be forever spinning.

Oh my God, Jamie. You said it. Perfect. Carry on.

And thank you thank you thank you for the amazing feedback. It means an incredible amount. ♥ ♥ ♥

Date: 2011-01-10 07:27 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] mollivanders.livejournal.com
This is unbearably gorgeous. You take Hermione's voice and give it such clarity, something we desperately lack in the books, and I love the way you show us how she views those events when she's all alone and she really doesn't have anyone else to come up with answers for her (or vice versa).

This is my favorite part though, because it's such a Ron fear and something Harry worries about with Ron and Hermione:

“I mean… D’you think he’ll start not caring about us so much?” He speaks carefully, and there’s something beneath his words that she senses is begging to come out.

She feels a flash of annoyance, because it’s not her role to dig his meaning out for him, and it’s so unfair that he expects her to do that, and make your own meaning, for goodness’ sake.

Then she remembers that yes, in fact, yes, this is her part. And it’s the one he trusts her to do, it’s the space he doesn’t trust anyone else to fill.

“That will never happen,” she answers him.


Her answer is just perfect. Absolutely love this <3

Date: 2011-01-11 01:35 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
Oh, thank you so much! So glad this works for you. :) (I've seen you round on Lauren's journal amidst the recent celebrating of our boy (♥) - so it means a lot coming from a fellow obsessive!)

something we desperately lack in the books

Yes!! That's what prompted the Hermione POV, really... Which I'm glad to hear works!

it's such a Ron fear and something Harry worries about with Ron and Hermione

Oh yeah, I was thinking a lot about Harry during this, as he is also my boy and he and Ron are more alike than one would think...

So yes, thanks again for the great feedback! It is very much appreciated. ♥

Date: 2011-01-11 01:55 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] mollivanders.livejournal.com
That's what prompted the Hermione POV, really... Which I'm glad to hear works!

haha, were you in on the why-doesn't-Hermione-get-a-character-arc rant? :p

Harry and Ron are so much alike and it breaks my heart when people try to villainize one or other to build up the other one because they would not stand for that! at all! if you ever write a post on this, I'd love to see it :)

it was well deserved <3

Date: 2011-01-11 02:32 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
You are too kind, I am certain. ;)

were you in on the why-doesn't-Hermione-get-a-character-arc rant?

Hah, I was, yes.

I totally agree - I love both my boys (and apparently that's a bit weird to say, that I'm equally invested in them both? oh well), and I actually value their relationship the most in the series, so it's always disheartening to see bashing of either one of them, or dismissal of their friendship.

if you ever write a post on this, I'd love to see it :)

Oh Lord, I had not planned on doing so, but maybe I should now! I'm having a lot of thoughts about the Trio lately. But I think there's already an essay somewhere about Ron's relationship with Harry - and how Ron is defined by having the same strengths as Harry (rather than being his opposite), but not being as good as Harry at those things? I can't for the life of me find it now, but it was great.

Date: 2011-07-03 11:04 pm (UTC)
verdant_fire: (hp: amortentia)
From: [personal profile] verdant_fire
YOU WROTE RON/HERMIONE

THE SHIP THAT COMBINES THE ALREADY-OFF-THE-CHARTS AWESOMENESS OF TWO OF MY FAVORITE CHARACTERS

I AM DOING THE DANCE OF JOY RIGHT NOW



I love the way you hit the major events in their relationship over the years, and that Hermione's pulled in because Ron isn't what she expected. <3

What really truly does shock, is the sight of him stumbling through the door, wand nervously raised, just a step behind his famously more heroic friend (whom she might have expected).

UGH, yes, Ron and his courage are so underrated. WEASLEY IS MY KING, OKAY. HATERS TO THE LEFT.

it just wouldn’t be logical, and rationality in these matters (of love, friendship and bravery) is what’s really necessary to hold on to.

LOL Hermione. I love her so much, and you write her very well.

The idea of them actually dancing together is preposterous, anyway. They’d fit all wrong, their timing would be completely off, and he would doubtless step on her toes a dozen times because this is who they are, after all.

And should they ever be in the position of being face-to-face, actually touching and connecting, her eyes would (misguidedly) find his, only for him to look away.

Or the other way around. They have always taken turns to make the wrong move.


UNF. I think you just summed up their relationship in a heartbreakingly brilliant way.

she knows that any attempt at showing him she cares will either be ignored or spat on, because that’s the easy way out in these matters, and she’s beginning to see the appeal.

So sad and true. :(

I love the way you used the parallelism of them saying each other's names. I am exceedingly pleased that you wrote this, and I enjoyed it immensely. xD

Date: 2011-07-04 05:42 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
YOU LOVE THEM TOO?

Photobucket


THANK YOU VERY MUCH, M'DEAR. I am EXCEEDINGLY PLEASED you enjoyed! <3

Date: 2012-03-16 03:04 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] rosaxx50.livejournal.com
This story is the most flawless thing ever.

The best Hermione voice (and character arc too), the best expanding on both their insecurities, the best whirlwind of both their emotions.

But (she is surprised to realise) she has long stopped defining perfection the way she used to.

THIS IS THE MOST ACCURATE AND INSIGHTFUL. It just works on so many levels.

Date: 2012-03-16 03:24 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] ever-neutral.livejournal.com
WHOA, your comment, lol. May be the nicest one I've received ever. I don't know what to say! Except thanks a bunch, and I'm thrilled this old thing resonated so much for you. Totally appreciate you dropping by.

Profile

ever_neutral: (Default)
ever_neutral

July 2025

S M T W T F S
  12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Jul. 10th, 2025 10:23 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios